Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Module 2 Project - Literature Review

Going through the resources found on the University of Houston's Digital Storytelling website turned to be a useful investment of time. The website defines Digital Storytelling as the use of computer-based tools to tell a story. The components suggested, are: images, text, recorded audio narration, video clips, and music. Bernard R. Robin (“Educational Use of Digital Storytelling”, p. 1), provides a similar definition:

combining the art of telling stories with a variety of digital  multimedia, such as images, audio, and video. Just about all digital stories bring together some mixture of digital graphics, text, recorded audio narration, video and music to present information on a specific topic.

The reviewed resources emphasized that Digital Stories are very similar to traditional stories in their focus on specific topic and containment of particular point of view. According to the Center of Digital Storytelling, California, Digital Stories are composed of 7 elements:

1.     Point of View
2.     A Dramatic Question
3.     Emotional Content
4.     The Gift of Your Voice
5.     The Power of the Sountrack
6.     Economy of Content
7.     Pacing.

The Digital Storytelling team at the University of Houston enhances the above list for the purpose of meeting educational needs as follows:

1.     The overall purpose of the story
2.     The narrator’s point of view
3.     A dramatic question or questions
4.     The choice of content
5.     Clarity of voice
6.     Pacing of the narrative
7.     Use of a meaningful audio soundtrack
8.     Quality of the images, video and other multimedia elements
9.     Economy of the story details
10.  Good grammar and language use

I found the latter list a very good instrument to devise a Marking Scheme for Assignments of this sort. It will be a very good tool to enhance the marking scheme the next time I setup a similar learning opportunity for the students. It’s too late to incorporate it in the current Assignment that I have already shared it’s outlines including the marking scheme with the students.

Dr. Jonassen et. Al provided in his paper (“How Does Technology Facilitate Learning”) many ways in which students can learn with technology rather than from it. I found that Digital Narrative do meet most of the criteria mentioned by Dr. Jonassen for technology to foster both learning and thinking. Bernard R. Robin’s, (“Educational Use of Digital Storytelling”, p. 5), validated my theory on the suitability of using Digital Narratives to foster students learning. Bernard had successfully identified the various literacy skills that the students would develop by working on Digital Narratives, to be:

1.     Research Skills: Documenting the story, finding and analyzing pertinent
information; 
2.     Writing Skills: Formulating a point of view and developing a script; 
3.     Organization Skills: Managing the scope of the project, the materials used and the time it takes to complete the task; 
4.     Technology Skills: learning to use a variety of tools, such as digital cameras, scanners, microphones and multimedia authoring software;  
5.     Presentation Skills: Deciding how to best present the story to an audience;
6.     Interview Skills: Finding sources to interview and determining questions to ask; 
7.     Interpersonal Skills: Working within a group and determining individual roles for group members; 
8.     Problem-Solving Skills: Learning to make decisions and overcome obstacles at all stages of the project, from inception to completion; and 
9.     Assessment Skills: Gaining expertise critiquing their own and others’ work.

The Digital Storytelling team at the University of Houston recommends Educational Digital Stories to range in length between 2 – 10 minutes. This is very close to the range I provided my students as a guiding reference, considering the nature of the MIS case study in hand.

A very nice sample Digital Narrative “on Digital Storytelling” was found and shared with the students as a reference too.

4 comments:

  1. Hi Baraa,

    I enjoyed reading your post. Digital Storytelling (and Storytelling in general) is an interest of mine although I have never taken the time to create much myself.

    Storytelling is also an important element in knowledge management. There is quite a lot in the literature and some classic research studies on how knowledge is transmitted in a work environment through stories. I know that I often hear knowledge being transmitted through stories in our break room. It will be interesting to see the kind of digital stories you and your students decide to tell.

    Dean

    PS. I've got a couple of books on this topic if you want to look at them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Bara'a,
    What a coincidence! For the last 3 summers I have been running a club, "The Art of Storytelling", during the summer program, 'Summer Challenge', run by CERT here at Al-Ain colleges for high school students. I find storytelling a very useful means to enhance young learners' language skills. I didn't know that the same was available in digital form too.
    Thank you for posting this up here. I watched the Sample Digital Narative just now and liked it....... plan to view your other links when I get more time. If you do intend to take this up formally involving your students, please do keep us updated of the progress.

    Baber

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Barra, It would seem particularly from the various skills that students could develop in the creation of digital stories identified by Robins that digital stories make an incredibly holistic assessment. Having taught on a multiliteracy course for student teachers I am very aware of the power of digital storytelling - our students create culturally appropriate e-books for young learners mainly but not exclusively using MS PPT which are extremely well received. It's a format that our B Ed Early Childhood Education students use in creating an assessment portfolio for a specific child in their class. This includes collaboration with the child who introduces him/herself and the portfolio and helps to select content which is used to celebrate their achievements relative to specific learning outcomes during the semester and incorporates evidence of learning in the form of audio, video, photos, work assignments and anecdotes from their class teacher, parents etc. Our students tend to use MS PowerPoint combined with AV clips which works well. I know that you planned to use YouTube for your narratives - will all your students use this and what software will they use to edit them?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All the students used YouTube, however, very few actually did the analysis that I expected them to do. YouTube comments used as the tool to conduct the discussion. Windows Movie Maker and Apple iMovie were utilized for the videos production. The fact most of the students turned the whole assignment to simply a recorded interview, made me reflect on the possibility to enhance the marking scheme to clearly state the requirements for evident analysis. I've done that and will publish more details on the experience in my following blog posts.

      Delete